That is a wrap, folks! Here is the Master Post for 2020!!!

Title: I Never Knew
Artist: ncdover1285
Author: midnightsilver
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: drinking
Summary: How can you know a person better than you know yourself but never know this? A drunken realization with a little help from a friend.

(aka: ‘of course you two love each other, shut up and kiss already’)

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Untouchable for Life
Artist: angeltortured
Author: sintari
Other Pairing(if applicable): Sam Winchester/Jessica Moore, briefly mentioned Dean Winchester/OFC
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Sex Work, Angst (see more at AO3), Jess Positive
Summary: When Stanford student Sam is desperate for rent money, his girlfriend Jess suggests he turn to camming. As his uneasy relationship with sex work progresses, Sam's "Top Fan," the lurker Impala67, leaves him conflicted.... and something else.

Art: Ao3
Story: Ao3

Title: Call of the Wolf
Artist: tx_devilorangel
Author: ncdover1285
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: N/A
Summary: Something is terrorizing a small town in South Dakota. Sets of siblings seem to disappear into the woods and never be seen again. What is being seen is a huge wolf that is lurking in the woods. Sam and Dean go to investigate. Will they figure out what is happening in this small town, or will they be another set of siblings that simply disappear?

Art: Live Journal | Ao3
Story: Ao3

Title: a sad fact of modern life
Artist: emmatheslayer
Author: thelegendofwinchester
Rating: G
Warnings/Spoilers: N/A
Summary: The boys make a YouTube channel with the intention to easily be able to spread knowledge to new hunters and help them out.

It goes downhill within minutes, but that’s not always a bad thing.

Art: Live Journal
Story: Ao3

Title: Cock Tails
Artist: ncdover1285
Author: angeltortured
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: drunk sex
Summary: Sam gets drunk off of phallic-shaped drinks at a gay bar.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Strap Your Hands 'Cross my Engines (Don't Mind Me, You Usually Don't)
Artist: midnightsilver​
Author: nevergettingoverwincest
Other Pairing(if applicable): Sam/Dean/Impala
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: N/A
Summary: “Hold your horses,” the witch called when Dean pounded on her door. Sam and Baby were behind him, Baby craning her neck to look in one of the cottage’s windows.

The door scraped open and the witch poked her head out. “Back already? Who’s this?” she added, looking at Baby.

“This is my car,” Dean said, flatly.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Darkness And Light
Artist: shealynn88
Author: ncdover1285
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Incest, M/M
Summary: Sam and Dean are cursed and they are sent on separate journeys to figure out how to break the curse. Finding out that they may just get exactly what they have been longing for is definitely a bonus.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Burn for You
Artist: darklittleheart96
Author: storyspinner70
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Dom/sub, Alpha Dean, Alpha Sam, Unusual ABO Dynamics, Possessive Dean Winchester, Dom Dean Winchester, Sub Sam Winchester, Bondage, Top Dean, Bottom Sam
Summary: No one was surprised when both Winchester boys became alphas. The surprise came when Sam figured out that, while he might be happy to be an alpha, the only place eh really wanted to be was on his knees for his brother.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Trust Me
Artist: ncdover1285
Author: amypond45
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Time travel, Humor, angst, Sam POV
Summary: Stanford Sam travels back in time to the week after he left for college to show Dean how much he loves him.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: Spellbound
Artist: tx_devilorangel
Author: theydraggedmeinowianintleaving
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: Alternate Universe - Canon Divergence, Past Jessica Moore/Sam Winchester, Canon Compliant, Up til season 3, not entirely canon compliant though, Dean Winchester Dies, Dean Winchester is saved from Hell, No Apocalypse, Angel Castiel (Supernatural), the angels are good guys, or at least neutral, Jealous Sam Winchester, Castiel & Dean Winchester Friendship, endgame wincest, Dean's crossroads deal, John Winchester Dies, implied wet dreams, Canon-Typical Violence, Sam Winchester Dies, but only for ten seconds, implied soulmates
Summary: Sam had always known they were outsiders; hadn’t needed the oh so helpful input from any Harry, Dick or Jane to realize as much when tv had already told him.
Or maybe he hadn’t always known; had once been young (and perhaps innocent) enough to not know any better. However, he’d learned; from blurry images on tiny tv-screens whenever their dad found it necessary to rent a motel room for the three of them.

On the screen everybody lived in houses rather than an old car driving from one end of the country and then back again over and over and over. Kids didn’t know how to use a gun – Sam might not yet be the marksman his brother was, but he knew how to use every single one in their dad’s arsenal; which was another thing the people on tv didn’t have: a goddamn arsenal of weapons.

Art: Live Journal | Ao3
Story: Ao3

Title: The Human Trap
Artist: bluefire986
Author: storyspinner70
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Biker Dean and Sam, Violence, Aftermath of torture, Hurt Dean, Protective Sam, Revenge
Summary: Dean and Sam Winchester were new to being the power behind The Knights of Hell biker gang, but they weren't new to the violence and pain that went along with it. They were working for a better future, but that was going to take muscle and brain and a lot of blood. Nothing worthwhile ever changed in a single day, but when Dean doesn't come back from a simple gun drop, The Knights worry that nothing will ever be the same again.

Art: Live Journal | Ao3
Story: Ao3

Title: There Will Be Peace When You Are Done/I'll Come Back To You
Artist: angeltortured
Author: specialgentrin
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: Major Character Death, Season 15 AU
Summary: This is it. The final battle against Chuck Shurley.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: No Retreat, No Surrender
Artist: bluefire986
Author: smalltrolven
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: N/A
Summary: After everything with Chuck is over, Sam and Dean move up to Rufus’ cabin in Montana, to finally retire. After the hunting life they’ve led, they know there’s plenty of people and monsters left out there that have a score to settle. All the monsters forgotten, memories avoided and choices made in the past make what happens next even worse.

Art: Live Journal | Ao3
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: Box Up My Heart
Artist: txdora
Author: levisqueaks
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: N/A
Summary: Moving in with Sam had been perfect. They were living the life at Stanford with the world and their futures spread before them for the taking. But sometimes Sam was swallowed up in pain, whiskey, and knives instead of sweet dreams.

One day Jessica stumbles across a secret Sam had been hiding for years and the darkness that takes over him begins to make sense.

Especially when they get an unexpected late-night visitor and she witnesses a secret kiss.

Art: Live Journal | Ao3
Story: Ao3

Title: A Little Sugar
Artist: emberthrace
Author: hit_the_books
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Canon-Typical Violence, Dubious Consent, Season 2, Recreational Drug Use, Explicit Sexual Content (see story for full tags)
Summary: People are dying bloodily in Red Bluff, California, and no one knows how. The only leads? A strange substance that may or may not be a narcotic and hints of sulfur, and the rumor that a local outlaw motorcycle gang may be involved.

Heading out to Northern California on the hunt, Dean and Sam are going to discover feelings they've been hiding from each other for a long time.

Art: Live Journal
Story: Ao3

Title: Payphone Symphony
Artist: emmatheslayer
Author: levisqueaks
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Alternate Universe - Canon Divergence, Angst, Barely Legal, Wincest, Dean Winchester/Sam Winchester, Older Sam Winchester, Younger Dean Winchester, Pining, Deception, Phone Sex, Dirty Talk, Sam Winchester is basically Dean’s Dad, Mechanic!Dean, Age Difference, Phone Sex Operator
Summary: Sam Winchester never claimed to be a righteous man but he hoped that his good deeds could someday outweigh the sin in his heart. After all, what 35 year old man, who practically raised their younger brother fell in love with them?

Sam finds a mysterious bill that sets off alarms. But when he overhears Dean greeting a caller using a known sex phone company’s name, Sam is tossed into a whirling sea of intrigue, deception, and longing.

Can Sam redeem himself? Or will becoming Dean’s most loyal customer only drag him closer to hell?

Art: Live Journal
Story: Ao3

Title: Under a Blue Moon
Artist: emberthrace
Author: amypond45
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: dubcon
Summary: While hunting a lycanthrope, Dean gets bit. Sam figures out a cure, but he knows Dean won’t like it.

Art: Live Journal
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: Spinning On That Dizzy Edge
Artist: angeltortured
Author: ratflavored
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Rough Oral
Summary: Sam’s tearing himself apart to finish the trials, so Dean forces them to have a night to relax in what he considers the bunker. But there's things going on behind Sam's poker face that Dean can't quite figure out.

Most of the time, Dean can let that sort of thing slide, but when he's loose with whiskey and mulling over memories, it's a lot harder. What does Sam want from him?

Booze, memories, and cards make for a dangerous combo.

Art: Twitter
Story: Ao3

Title: Titans Remembered
Artist: midnightsilver
Author: klove0511
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: Brief, non-graphic attempted bestiality; referenced animal sacrifice, hurt Dean
Summary: Following a string of missing people and livestock mutilations, Sam and Dean stumble on a case where the monster has a personal beef with them. When Dean gets himself in trouble trying to do everything himself, Sam must come to the rescue and remind him that they're better as a team.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3 | Tumblr

Title: Wish Not Change
Artist: kelios
Author: smalltrolven
Rating: R
Warnings/Spoilers: spoilers for season 15
Summary: There’s a picture that Dean has in his wallet. It’s of the two of them, even though it’s not really them, but it’s still the stuff that wishes are made of. It takes a journey to New Orleans and back, a new case opened and closed, and wishes made and granted, for that wish to maybe come true.

Art: Live Journal
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: Free Bird
Artist: darklittleheart96
Author: merenwen76
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: ExSlave!Dean, Hunter!Sam, Implied/Referenced Rape/Non, NSFW Art
Summary: Written for the following prompt: Non-brothers AU, Sam (35 or older) is one of the best hunter, whose whole life has changed the day he rescued terrified and abused slave named Dean, who within the law is now Sam's slave...

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: The Boy Who Would be King
Artist: sarasaurussex
Author: annie46
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: NSFW art, character death
Summary: Without a soul Sam can be what he was always meant to be - King of Hell. He doesn't need Dean, or does he? Dean only wants to save Sam, or does he actually want more?

Art: Tumblr
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: What Doesn’t Kill You Makes Us Stronger
Artist: shealynn88
Author: ncdover1285
Other Pairing(if applicable): Dean Winchester/ others (mentioned), Sam Winchester/ Others (mentioned)
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Dark, M/M, Unknown Incest, Dark Winchesters
Summary: Sam and Dean grew up in different ways, but seem to have quite a bit in common. Both finding their way to a life of killing and lies. It’s almost as if something is keeping one from killing the other though when they take the other as a mark.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Moral Insanity
Artist: midnightsilver
Author: levisqueaks
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Crack, This Seemed Like A Good Idea At The Time, Dean Winchester Wears Panties, Cowboy Sam Winchester, The Boys Film a Porno
Summary: When Dean got down to it, this was all Sammy’s fault. The road to hell is paved with good intentions, but when Sam convinces Dean they should make money by filming porn rather than credit card scams, the brothers end up a little too close to the fire.

Why did he feel like he was walking to the gallows? He loved porn. He was a fine curator of porn. Had been since his first skin mag at 13. So why was the thought of being behind the camera so nerve wracking?

Once Dean’s eyes had adjusted to the darkness beyond the wall separating them from the storefront he found the director circling Sam. Like a shark. This guy was a shark. Or maybe a vampire? He was some sort of deadly with teeth that wanted to eat his kid brother alive.
What the hell had they gotten themselves in to?

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: The Hawk and the Wolf
Artist: kelios
Author: fledhyris
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: N/A
Summary: Two brothers, cursed for loving one another a little too closely, wander as knights errant, together yet forever apart. Their luck turns when Dean encounters a young thief, Garth, running from Winchester Cathedral with a stolen book. They have just one chance to meet the conditions for the spell to be lifted; will they win their hearts’ desire or be doomed to live out the rest of their lives under a cruel enchantment?

Art: Live Journal
Story: Ao3

Title: stumbling over universes
Artist: kuwlshadow
Author: embersdevine
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: Some sexual content
Summary: Sam and Dean find themselves in another world. Again. But someone finds them and it sort of changes everything.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Titanium (With You On the Edge of Every Tomorrow)
Artist: darklittleheart
Author: abeautifullie3
Other Pairing(if applicable): (all minor or passing mentions) Charlie/Eileen. Jody/Donna. Cesar/Jesse. OFC/OMC.
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: (full list at author’s LJ or AO3, here be the biggies) Spoilers through entire aired series…just to be safe. Semi-AU. Canon Divergence. A/B/O. Mpreg. Alpha!Dean. Alpha-to-Omega!Sam. A Few Instances of Gore. Graphic OC Deaths. Death of Not-A-Fucking-Lead Character. Graphic Deaths of Minors (not Sam and Dean's). Show Level Violence. Profanity. Graphic Sex. BDSM: A Bit of B…With Some D&S…No S&M. Pregnancy!Kink. Lactation!Kink. Pregnant!Sex. To Be Safe: Graphic Births. Kid!fic. Kinda-sorta Curtain!Fic. Kinda-sorta Fix-It!Fic. Angst. A Bit of Schmoop To Sooth.
Summary: All the sigils, all the wards. All the hoodoo and white magic. All of the mystical safeguards they had in place, and yet there was one thing none of it could protect them from... Humans.

Against the odds, Dean and Sam have built a life together aside from Hunting. With the help of a curse-turned-gift, they’ve even made their own family. Now, Sam eight months pregnant with his and Dean’s daughter, it’s all being threatened when Dean and their five-year-old son, Jameson, are abducted.

It's perfectly executed. As if the kidnapper knows personal details about Sam and Dean's lives. Has knowledge – and access – to the bunker. Has been to their home.
It's because she does and has.
She's been training with them for over two years. Moved up in the ranks to both helper and friend. Hell, she's watched after Jameson for them.
She's been biding her time.

Now it’s Dean’s turn to bide his time, take care of his son as best he can while being held prisoner, keep them alive until Sam can rescue them. Which, if there is anything Dean knows for sure…Sam will save them.

The weeks passing, stress taking its toll on Sam’s heavily pregnant body, with what little Sam and his people have to go on, what they’ve been able to piece together, he knows it’s up to him to find and rescue his brother and son from a sadistic psychopath who may be right in their midst.

Semi-AU from season 6 finale. Some canon stuffs after that still happened. A helluva bunch didn’t…or played out differently. No time for significant “world building”, and not a primary focus, but this is A/B/O.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: stumbling over universes
Artist: kuwlshadow
Author: embersdevine
Rating: PG-13
Warnings/Spoilers: Some sexual content
Summary: Sam and Dean find themselves in another world. Again. But someone finds them and it sort of changes everything.

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Moral Insanity
Artist: MidnightSilver
Author: LeviSqueaks
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Crack, This Seemed Like A Good Idea At The Time, Dean Winchester Wears Panties, Cowboy Sam Winchester, The Boys Film a Porno
Summary: When Dean got down to it, this was all Sammy’s fault. The road to hell is paved with good intentions, but when Sam convinces Dean they should make money by filming porn rather than credit card scams, the brothers end up a little too close to the fire.
–
Why did he feel like he was walking to the gallows? He loved porn. He was a fine curator of porn. Had been since his first skin mag at 13. So why was the thought of being behind the camera so nerve wracking?

Once Dean’s eyes had adjusted to the darkness beyond the wall separating them from the storefront he found the director circling Sam. Like a shark. This guy was a shark. Or maybe a vampire? He was some sort of deadly with teeth that wanted to eat his kid brother alive.
What the hell had they gotten themselves in to?

Art: Tumblr
Story: Ao3

Title: Wish Not Change
Artist: kelios
Author: smalltrolven
Rating: R
Warnings/Spoilers: spoilers for season 15
Summary: There’s a picture that Dean has in his wallet. It’s of the two of them, even though it’s not really them, but it’s still the stuff that wishes are made of. It takes a journey to New Orleans and back, a new case opened and closed, and wishes made and granted, for that wish to maybe come true.

Art: Live Journal
Story: Live Journal | Ao3

Title: Payphone Symphony
Artist: EmmatheSlayer
Author: LeviSqueaks
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Alternate Universe - Canon Divergence, Angst, Barely Legal, Wincest, Dean Winchester/Sam Winchester, Older Sam Winchester, Younger Dean Winchester, Pining, Deception, Phone Sex, Dirty Talk, Sam Winchester is basically Dean’s Dad, Mechanic!Dean, Age Difference, Phone Sex Operator
Summary: Sam Winchester never claimed to be a righteous man but he hoped that his good deeds could someday outweigh the sin in his heart. After all, what 35 year old man, who practically raised their younger brother fell in love with them?

Sam finds a mysterious bill that sets off alarms. But when he overhears Dean greeting a caller using a known sex phone company’s name, Sam is tossed into a whirling sea of intrigue, deception, and longing.

Can Sam redeem himself? Or will becoming Dean’s most loyal customer only drag him closer to hell?

Art: Live Journal
Story: Ao3